Formal Reviews of two Articles

Journal Article Review Instructions

 

 

 

During this course, you will write formal reviews on 2 online articles. During Module/Week 3, you will review the following article:

 

 

 

First Article

 

“The Origin of Old-Earth Geology and its Ramifications for Life in the 21^st Century” by Terry Mortenson at http://www.answersingenesis.org/articles/tj/v18/n1/old-earth-geology.

 

 

 

Second Article

 

“East Africa’s Great Rift Valley: A Complex Rift System” by James Wood and Alex Guth at http://geology.com/articles/east-africa-rift.shtml.

 

 

 

Content

 

In general, each Journal Article Review must contain an introductory paragraph, the body of the work, and a conclusion. In terms of the body, the following items must be discussed:

 

1.     Brief overview of the theme of the article and its main points.

 

2.     Strengths of the article. Answer questions such as:

 

a.     What did the author do well?

 

b.     Were any points made exceptionally clear?

 

c.     Did the author write with concision and precision?

 

3.     Weaknesses of the article. Answer questions such as:

 

a.     What erroneous assumptions does the author make, if any?

 

b.     Are any factual errors made in the article?

 

c.     Is the scientific method violated in any way?

 

d.     Could the author have stated his/her case better?

 

4.     Remember, every article has weaknesses. You are expected to discuss some of these. Failure to identify any weaknesses in your Journal Article Reviews will negatively affect your grade.

 

 

 

Outline

 

Use the following outline when writing your papers. Each point on the below outline must be a separate section (with a section heading) within each of your Journal Article Reviews. You will notice that these section headings correspond to the content points above.

 

I.               Introduction

 

II.             Brief Overview and Main Points

 

III.           Article Strengths

 

IV.           Article Weaknesses

 

V.             Conclusion

 

 

Length

 

These reviews are to be 2–3 pages each. Do not exceed this page limit. The title page and bibliography do not count toward this page total.

 

 

 

Format

 

You must use current APA formatting. Papers must be double-spaced with 1-inch margins all around. The font is to be Courier New or Times New Roman, 12-point. Include a cover sheet with your name, instructor’s name, course number and title, date, and paper title. There is no need to include an abstract in your paper.

 

 

 

Sources

 

The only source required for each review is the article itself. However, feel free to incorporate other sources if you so desire. Additional sources must be limited to journal articles, manuscripts, scholarly textbooks, and/or internet sites from .edu or .gov sources. Avoid internet sites from .com, .net, .org, etc. sources as the information contained therein are not often peer-reviewed. Also, Study Bibles are not appropriate for this assignment. List all of your sources in a bibliography at the end of the paper.

 

 

 

Citation

 

Be sure to cite your sources in the body of your paper using proper APA formatting.